A Real-World Year With a Heat Pump: What Does It Actually Cost?

Reading Time: 4 minutes

Heat pumps are often compared with gas boilers simply by looking at the price of a unit of gas against a unit of electricity.

That comparison misses the most important part of the equation: the amount of useful heat produced from each unit of purchased energy.

We have therefore taken a complete year of real-world heat-pump data from an existing home and applied October 2026 energy prices to it.

This isn’t a laboratory test or a modelled new-build. It is measured data from an occupied 1940s semi-detached home in the West Midlands, with conventional loft and wall insulation and triple glazing.

The real-world data

For the 12-month period from June 2025 to May 2026, the heat pump recorded:

MeasurementActual result
Useful heat delivered8,519.83 kWh
Electricity consumed2,440.23 kWh
Seasonal Performance Factor (SPF)3.49
Electricity used 23:30–05:301,794.89 kWh
Electricity used outside that period645.34 kWh
Share shifted into the overnight period73.6%

The important numbers are the first two.

The house required 8,520 kWh of useful heat, but the heat pump only needed 2,440 kWh of electricity to produce it.

For every 1 kWh of electricity consumed, the system delivered approximately 3.49 kWh of heat.

Why useful heat matters

A gas boiler and a heat pump work very differently.

A boiler converts the chemical energy in gas into heat. Even a reasonably efficient modern boiler does not turn every kWh of gas into a kWh of useful heat.

Assuming 90% seasonal efficiency, producing the same 8,519.83 kWh of heat would require:

8,519.83 ÷ 0.90 = 9,466.48 kWh of gas

The heat pump required:

2,440.23 kWh of electricity.

So to provide exactly the same amount of heat:

SystemPurchased energyUseful heat
90% gas boiler9,466 kWh gas8,520 kWh
Real heat pump2,440 kWh electricity8,520 kWh

The heat pump therefore used approximately 74% less purchased energy.

That’s why comparing 1 kWh of electricity with 1 kWh of gas doesn’t tell you what heating a home actually costs.

What would that year cost at October 2026 prices?

From 1 October to 31 December 2026, Ofgem’s GB-average Direct Debit price cap is 26.32p/kWh for electricity and 7.97p/kWh for gas. The average gas standing charge is 29.68p/day. Ofgem

We can apply those prices to the actual measured heat requirement.

Heating optionAnnual costCost per kWh of useful heat
Gas boiler – Ofgem cap£86310.13p
Heat pump – all electricity at Ofgem cap£6427.54p
Heat pump – smart tariff with measured shifting£3123.66p
Heat pump – PolicySeed 15p/7.5p£2312.72p

For gas we have included the approximately £108 annual gas standing charge, because an all-electric home does not need to maintain a separate gas connection.

We have not added the electricity standing charge to the heat-pump figures because the household needs an electricity connection regardless of how it is heated.

Even without a smart tariff, the heat pump wins

This is an important result.

Suppose the household did absolutely no clever load shifting and bought every single kWh used by the heat pump at Ofgem’s October electricity price-cap rate of 26.32p/kWh.

The annual heating electricity would cost approximately:

£642

The equivalent gas heating would cost approximately:

£863

So despite electricity costing more than three times as much per purchased kWh as gas, the heat pump would still be approximately £221 cheaper over this real-world year.

That’s the efficiency advantage in action.

The heat pump doesn’t need 8,520 kWh of electricity to deliver 8,520 kWh of heat. It needed just 2,440 kWh.

Smart tariffs completely change the economics

This installation also demonstrates another advantage of electrified heating: when electricity is consumed matters.

Of the 2,440 kWh consumed by the heat pump during the year, 1,795 kWh – 73.6% – was consumed between 23:30 and 05:30.

Using the smart-tariff rates in this case study of 6.66p/kWh off-peak and 29.76p/kWh peak, the calculation becomes:

1,794.89 kWh × 6.66p = £119.54

645.34 kWh × 29.76p = £192.05

Total:

£311.59 for the year

That works out at only 3.66p for each kWh of useful heat delivered to the home.

Compared with approximately £863 for gas, that’s a saving of around:

£551 a year

And crucially, this isn’t based on assuming that a household could shift 70% of its heating overnight.

The measured data shows that it actually did.

What happens under the PolicySeed electricity tariff?

PolicySeed proposes bringing domestic electricity prices substantially closer to the underlying economics of an increasingly electrified energy system.

Our proposed rates are:

15p/kWh peak
7.5p/kWh off-peak

Applying exactly the same measured consumption pattern gives:

1,794.89 kWh × 7.5p = £134.62

645.34 kWh × 15p = £96.80

Total annual heat-pump electricity:

£231.42

That means each kWh of useful heat delivered to the house costs just:

2.72p/kWh

Compare that with 10.13p/kWh of useful heat from gas at October 2026 prices.

The heat pump would produce useful heat for roughly 73% less.

Gas would have to become very cheap

This also illustrates why PolicySeed places so much emphasis on reducing the daytime electricity price rather than relying entirely on special heat-pump tariffs.

At 15p/kWh peak, a heat pump with an SPF around 3.5 is already extraordinarily competitive with gas.

With the actual load shifting achieved in this house, the PolicySeed tariff produces an annual heat cost of only £231.

For a 90%-efficient gas boiler to produce the same heat for £231, while also paying today’s gas standing charge, the gas commodity price would have to fall to roughly:

1.3p/kWh

Even if we generously ignored the gas standing charge altogether, gas would need to cost only about:

2.44p/kWh

That compares with 7.97p/kWh today. Ofgem

In other words, gas prices could fall substantially from today’s level and this particular heat pump would still remain highly competitive under the PolicySeed electricity tariff.

This is why electricity prices matter

The transition away from gas doesn’t necessarily require households to consume enormous quantities of electricity.

This real-world house needed 8.52 MWh of heat, but the heat pump required only 2.44 MWh of electricity to provide it.

The bigger problem is the price attached to each unit of electricity.

Even at today’s standard electricity price cap, this real-world heat pump beats the equivalent gas heating cost.

Give households access to smart off-peak electricity and the advantage becomes enormous.

Bring the normal electricity rate down towards 15p/kWh, while retaining a 7.5p off-peak incentive, and the economics change fundamentally.

Heat pumps don’t need electricity to be cheaper than gas per kWh.

They need electricity to be priced sensibly enough for their efficiency advantage to show through.

That is why PolicySeed believes 15p peak / 7.5p off-peak electricity can make electrification the economically obvious choice — without banning gas or forcing households to switch.

Methodology note

This is a single-home case study and should not be interpreted as the performance every heat pump will achieve. Heat-pump performance depends on building fabric, system design, flow temperatures, weather, controls and occupant behaviour. Gas comparison assumes 90% boiler efficiency. October 2026 Ofgem figures are GB-average Direct Debit rates; actual capped rates vary by region and payment method. Ofgem also notes that the price cap applies to default tariffs rather than fixed tariffs. Ofgem

Official price source: Ofgem — Energy price cap unit rates and standing charges

Sources data: