National Energy Task Force

Reading Time: 11 minutes

How a government would implement Policy Seed’s National Electricity Tariff and wider electricity market reforms.

Overview

Policy Seed believes that Britain’s high electricity prices represent a national economic challenge that requires a coordinated government response.

Electricity is an essential service. Its cost affects households, businesses, manufacturing, transport and the wider economy. Reducing electricity prices should therefore be treated as a national economic priority rather than left to the existing system of market incentives and regulatory consultations.

Our proposed National Electricity Tariff has a clear objective: to deliver affordable, predictable electricity prices, with a standard domestic rate of 15p/kWh and lower overnight rates, supported by reforms to network charging, policy costs and energy taxation.

However, announcing a new tariff is not enough.

Electricity suppliers, network operators, regulators and other industry participants would all need to make changes to the way electricity is priced, billed, financed and administered.

These reforms cannot depend entirely on voluntary cooperation from an industry whose commercial interests may not always align with the proposed changes.

Policy Seed therefore proposes establishing a National Energy Reform Task Force with the statutory authority to coordinate, direct and enforce the implementation of the reforms.

The principle is straightforward: Parliament determines the policy, government establishes the implementation framework, and the energy industry is legally required to deliver it.

1. Treating energy affordability as a national priority

During the COVID-19 pandemic, the UK demonstrated that government could mobilise resources, coordinate public and private organisations, introduce emergency legislation and implement substantial changes at national scale.

Policy Seed believes that a similar level of urgency and coordination should be applied to electricity affordability.

This does not mean that high electricity prices constitute the same type of emergency as a pandemic, or that existing emergency legislation should be used without proper justification.

It means recognising that problems affecting the whole economy require national leadership, clearly defined responsibilities and accelerated implementation.

Under the current arrangements, changes to electricity tariffs and market structures can involve multiple organisations, lengthy consultations, licence modifications and technical implementation programmes.

Those processes serve important purposes, but they can also make comprehensive reform difficult to coordinate.

Policy Seed proposes a single national programme responsible for ensuring that the necessary changes happen together, within an agreed timetable.

The programme would have three overarching objectives:

  1. Deliver affordable electricity for households and businesses.
  2. Establish a transparent and sustainable system for financing electricity infrastructure and existing policy obligations.
  3. Maintain secure, reliable electricity supplies throughout the transition.

2. Establishing the National Energy Reform Task Force

A government adopting Policy Seed’s electricity reforms would establish a National Energy Reform Task Force through dedicated legislation.

We propose an Energy Reform and Affordability Act to provide the necessary statutory authority.

The task force would operate under the strategic direction of the Secretary of State responsible for energy and would be accountable to Parliament.

Its membership would include experienced representatives from government, electricity regulation, consumer protection, electricity supply, networks, system operation, finance and technology.

Consumer interests would be represented directly, rather than relying exclusively on industry participation.

The task force would be responsible for converting the government’s energy policy into operational requirements for the electricity sector.

Its statutory powers

Within the remit established by Parliament, the task force would have authority to:

  • Issue legally binding directions to licensed electricity suppliers and relevant industry organisations.
  • Mandate the implementation of the National Electricity Tariff.
  • Require changes to electricity billing, customer accounts and tariff administration.
  • Direct the implementation of the National Network Access Charge.
  • Require transparent reporting of policy costs and electricity charges.
  • Initiate and direct relevant licence and industry code modifications.
  • Require operational, technical and financial information from regulated businesses.
  • Establish and enforce implementation deadlines.
  • Direct specified changes to network charging, settlement and market arrangements.
  • Investigate non-compliance and impose proportionate statutory sanctions.

These powers would be expressly defined in legislation and subject to oversight and legal safeguards.

The intention would not be to create an unrestricted authority over the entire energy industry.

It would be to give government a legally effective mechanism for delivering a specific national reform programme.

3. The relationship with Ofgem

Ofgem currently regulates electricity suppliers and network operators and oversees substantial parts of the energy market.

Policy Seed proposes that the task force would temporarily exercise specified regulatory powers currently held by Ofgem where necessary to implement the new policy.

Within its statutory remit, the task force would have the authority to override conflicting Ofgem regulatory decisions and issue binding implementation directions.

Ofgem would continue exercising regulatory functions outside the task force’s responsibilities, including consumer protection, compliance and other ongoing regulatory duties.

This arrangement would provide a single source of authority for the reform programme without requiring the immediate replacement of every existing regulatory function.

The task force would be responsible for delivering the changes authorised by Parliament, rather than allowing the existing regulatory process to determine whether those changes should occur.

It is important to distinguish between consultation and decision-making.

Industry consultation would remain necessary to identify technical challenges, implementation costs, unintended consequences and opportunities to improve delivery.

However, consultation would not provide a veto over an approved national policy.

4. Mandatory implementation by electricity suppliers

Every licensed domestic electricity supplier operating within the policy’s geographical scope would be required to implement the National Electricity Tariff.

Suppliers would need to make coordinated changes to their existing systems, including:

  • Customer tariff structures and pricing arrangements.
  • Electricity billing platforms.
  • Standing charge and network charge calculations.
  • Smart meter and time-of-use billing.
  • Direct Debit, prepayment and customer account systems.
  • Existing fixed-term tariff transition arrangements.
  • Customer statements and communications.
  • Regulatory and financial reporting.

The task force would publish a common technical implementation standard to ensure consistency across suppliers.

This would include standard definitions, billing requirements, data formats, calculation methods and reporting obligations.

Suppliers would be given defined deadlines for implementation, supported by testing and compliance requirements.

The aim would be to avoid a situation in which individual suppliers develop different interpretations of the national policy.

Consumers should receive the same nationally defined tariff structure regardless of which licensed supplier administers their electricity account.

Protecting existing customers

The transition would need to account for households with existing fixed-term contracts, prepayment meters, outstanding balances and additional support requirements.

Suppliers would be required to provide clear explanations of how existing arrangements would change.

The task force would establish protections to prevent consumers being unfairly penalised for changes mandated by government.

5. Implementing the National Network Access Charge

A central part of Policy Seed’s proposal is the replacement of regional domestic electricity standing charges with a more transparent National Network Access Charge.

Under the proposed arrangements:

  • Standard domestic households would pay a fixed £25 monthly Network Access Charge.
  • Qualifying low-usage households would pay a reduced £12.50 monthly charge.
  • The existing system of regional domestic electricity standing charges would be replaced.

The charge would be administered through suppliers’ billing systems, with revenues distributed through an approved network funding mechanism.

The task force would be responsible for ensuring that network companies continue receiving the funding necessary to maintain, operate and develop the electricity network.

It would oversee the required changes to network charging methodologies, supplier payment arrangements and revenue reconciliation.

This is an important distinction.

Policy Seed is not proposing that electricity networks should operate without funding.

It is proposing a different and more transparent way of recovering those costs from domestic consumers, alongside a review of how the overall network is financed.

The transition would therefore require a properly reconciled financial settlement to ensure that network operators remain financially viable.

6. Making existing electricity policy costs visible

Consumers should be able to understand what they are paying for.

At present, several government electricity policy schemes recover costs through electricity suppliers, with those costs ultimately reflected in customer prices.

Examples include the Renewables Obligation and Feed-in Tariff arrangements.

Policy Seed proposes reforming how designated policy obligations are financed, including transferring eligible costs from electricity bills to general taxation where provided for in the policy.

This would not automatically eliminate those obligations.

Instead, it would change the mechanism through which they are funded.

A new requirement for billing transparency

The task force would introduce mandatory billing transparency requirements.

Suppliers would be required to disclose the relevant policy costs included in electricity charges using a standard methodology.

As the reforms were introduced, customer bills would identify the changes in those costs and explain their impact.

For example, customers would be able to see:

  • Their electricity consumption and applicable unit rates.
  • Their National Network Access Charge.
  • The policy costs previously recovered through electricity bills.
  • The policy costs removed or transferred under the reforms.
  • The effect of changes to electricity VAT.
  • A comparable estimate of their bill under the previous and new arrangements.

These comparisons would use the same consumption assumptions to avoid misleading claims about savings.

Where policy costs were transferred to general taxation, this would be disclosed rather than described as an elimination of the underlying financial obligation.

Our objective is that households should be able to see both the reduction in their electricity bills and the reasons for that reduction.

The task force would establish independent verification and reporting arrangements to ensure that the savings intended by government were reflected in actual customer charges.

7. Reforming the wider electricity system

The task force’s remit would not stop at domestic electricity suppliers.

Electricity prices are influenced by a combination of generation costs, network charges, system balancing, policy obligations, taxation and retail supply costs.

Successful reform therefore requires coordination across the wider electricity system.

Electricity networks

Transmission and distribution operators would be required to cooperate with the task force on the implementation of new charging and funding arrangements.

The task force could direct changes to relevant network charging methodologies and regulatory processes within its statutory remit.

It would also oversee reforms intended to improve cost transparency, investment planning and the efficient use of existing infrastructure.

Network operators would remain responsible for the safe operation and maintenance of their assets.

National Energy System Operator

The National Energy System Operator (NESO) has responsibilities for electricity system operation, planning and the coordination of the wider energy system.

The task force would have powers to require NESO to provide information, undertake analysis and implement authorised changes to relevant charging, planning and market arrangements.

This could include reforms relating to balancing costs, constraint management, network utilisation and market settlement.

However, NESO would retain the necessary operational independence to manage the electricity system safely.

The task force would not be permitted to issue directions that compromise grid stability, system security or emergency operation.

Electricity generation

The task force would be authorised to coordinate reforms affecting the commercial and regulatory arrangements under which electricity generation participates in the market.

This could include reviewing settlement mechanisms, market rules, future procurement arrangements and the recovery of system costs.

The objective would be to improve efficiency and ensure that lower costs within the electricity system can translate into lower consumer prices.

The task force would not have unrestricted authority to rewrite existing generation agreements or impose retrospective changes outside the law.

8. Protecting existing contracts and investment

Policy Seed recognises the importance of legal certainty.

Electricity infrastructure requires substantial long-term investment, often supported by contracts and regulatory arrangements extending over decades.

Our policy does not advocate unilaterally cancelling existing Contracts for Difference, withdrawing accrued Renewables Obligation entitlements or tearing up lawful commercial agreements.

The task force’s authority would be limited by the statutory protections established in the reform legislation.

Changing how an existing obligation is financed is different from cancelling the obligation itself.

For example, if government decided to transfer the cost of an existing electricity policy scheme from customer bills to general taxation, the underlying legal obligation could remain in place while the payment mechanism changed.

That would require proper legislation, financial provision and consideration of existing contractual rights.

Where existing agreements could not lawfully be changed without consent, the task force would need to respect those limits or seek a negotiated arrangement.

This approach is intended to protect investor confidence while allowing future market rules and funding arrangements to change.

9. A phased implementation programme

Policy Seed does not suggest that every electricity market reform can be completed overnight.

Electricity billing platforms, industry settlement systems and financial arrangements are complex and must be changed carefully.

However, the complexity of these systems should not become a reason for indefinite delay.

We propose a phased programme with defined deliverables, statutory deadlines and regular public reporting.

Phase 1 — Establishment and transparency

Indicative period: first quarter

The government would introduce the necessary legislation, establish the task force and begin the formal implementation programme.

The task force would issue initial supplier directions, prepare common billing standards and establish the technical requirements for the National Electricity Tariff.

Suppliers would begin implementing the requirement to disclose designated existing policy costs on electricity bills.

Phase 2 — Network charging reform

Indicative period: second quarter

The task force would implement the framework for replacing regional domestic standing charges with the National Network Access Charge.

This would include supplier billing changes, revised network charging methodologies and arrangements for distributing revenue to network operators.

Implementation would depend on a verified financial settlement that maintains network funding.

Phase 3 — Policy funding reform

Indicative period: third quarter

Government would introduce the legislated changes necessary to transfer designated electricity policy costs away from consumer bills.

The task force would coordinate the resulting changes to supplier charges, industry payments, reporting and customer billing.

The Treasury would be required to establish the corresponding funding arrangements.

Phase 4 — National tariff completion

Indicative period: fourth quarter

The National Electricity Tariff would be rolled out under the approved framework, including the proposed 15p/kWh standard domestic rate, lower overnight rates and the new charging structure.

The proposed reduction in domestic electricity VAT from 5% to 3.75% would be implemented through the appropriate tax legislation.

The government would publish an independent assessment comparing household electricity costs before and after the reform.

Phase 5 — Continued market improvement

Following the initial implementation period

The task force would oversee any outstanding technical changes and further reforms necessary to improve wholesale market efficiency, balancing costs, network charging and long-term electricity affordability.

These indicative phases would become legally enforceable milestones once the detailed implementation programme had been approved.

The timetable would incorporate technical testing, financial verification and system security requirements.

10. Funding the transition

Establishing a national tariff would require a credible financial framework.

A lower retail electricity price cannot be sustained simply by requiring suppliers to sell electricity below their recoverable costs without an alternative funding or procurement mechanism.

The task force would therefore operate alongside a Treasury-approved financing programme.

This would address:

  • The transfer of designated policy costs from electricity bills to general taxation.
  • Changes to the recovery of network costs.
  • The reduction in domestic electricity VAT.
  • Supplier billing and systems implementation costs.
  • Funding arrangements needed to deliver the national tariff.
  • An Energy Resilience Fund to manage exceptional wholesale market conditions.
  • The treatment of existing contractual and regulatory obligations.

The task force would be required to publish financial assessments demonstrating that the reform was adequately funded and that essential electricity supply and network services remained viable.

Policy Seed recognises that the proposed tariff is a destination to be achieved through coordinated reform, rather than a price that can be declared independently of the underlying costs.

Further details of the financial assumptions, funding mechanisms and estimated fiscal effects would be provided in our supporting policy cost assessment.

11. Parliamentary oversight and safeguards

The National Energy Reform Task Force would be given substantial powers, but those powers would remain subject to democratic and legal accountability.

Policy Seed proposes the following safeguards.

Parliamentary accountability: The task force would publish quarterly reports covering implementation progress, costs, savings and compliance.

Independent financial oversight: The financial effects of the programme would be subject to independent audit and published scrutiny.

Legal protections: Decisions would remain subject to judicial review and appropriate statutory appeal mechanisms.

Grid security: The task force would be explicitly prohibited from issuing directions that compromise electrical safety or secure system operation.

Consumer protections: Vulnerable customers would retain appropriate protections throughout implementation.

Time-limited authority: Exceptional implementation powers would expire after an initial two-year period unless renewed by Parliament.

Defined legal scope: Any power to override existing regulation would apply only to matters expressly authorised by the reform legislation.

These safeguards would allow the programme to proceed with urgency without creating an unaccountable permanent authority.

12. What happens when the reforms are complete?

The task force would not be intended as a permanent addition to the energy regulatory system.

Its purpose would be to implement a defined programme of reform.

Once the core changes had been completed and independently verified, its temporary statutory powers would expire.

Ongoing responsibilities would transfer to the permanent regulatory arrangements established under Policy Seed’s wider energy reform proposals, including the proposed Energy Consumer Commission.

This would provide continuity of consumer protection and oversight without retaining an emergency-style implementation structure indefinitely.

Conclusion: From policy to implementation

Britain’s electricity affordability challenge cannot be resolved simply by publishing targets or asking the industry to find ways to lower prices.

Delivering a new national electricity tariff requires changes across supply, billing, taxation, network charging, policy funding and parts of the wider wholesale market.

Those changes need to be coordinated.

Policy Seed proposes that government should establish a National Energy Reform Task Force with the authority, resources and legal powers needed to implement the reforms approved by Parliament.

The task force would have the power to require compliance, coordinate industry-wide changes and overcome regulatory obstacles within its defined remit.

It would not be permitted to cancel existing contracts arbitrarily, ignore financial obligations or compromise electricity system security.

The objective would be to create a clear separation of responsibilities:

Parliament establishes the law. Government sets the objectives. The task force coordinates and enforces delivery. Industry implements the required changes. Independent oversight verifies the results.

Ultimately, the success of this programme would not be judged by the number of consultations completed, regulatory changes introduced or reports published.

It would be judged by whether households and businesses receive affordable, reliable electricity at the prices the policy is designed to deliver.

The National Electricity Tariff is the destination. The National Energy Reform Task Force is the proposed mechanism for getting there.

Policy Seed — Supporting Policy Proposal

This document sets out a proposed legislative and implementation framework. The task force, its statutory powers and the proposed tariff arrangements are policy proposals, not existing legal powers or enacted government measures. Implementation would require legislation, detailed financial assessment and technical consultation.